Day 10, 2026: Massey's Pizza Sports Bar & Wings (Columbus, OH)

 
exterior  

DAY 10: OCTOBER 10th, 2026 

LOCATION: Massey's Pizza Sports Bar & Wings (Graceland Shopping Center, 152 Graceland Blvd, Columbus, OH 43214)

GUEST(S): Kitzi Taylor, Jay Taylor, Lori Taylor

ORDER: 6 slices of 14" Pepperoni, 3 slices of 8" Buffalo Chicken (Chicken breast, spicy pizza sauce, buffalo sauce, mozzarella, provolone), 2 slices of 8" Veggie (Onions, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Black Olives, Banana Peppers, Mozzarella, Provolone), 3 slices of 8" Meat Feast (ground beef, ham, salami, pepperoni, sausage, mozzarella, provolone)

REVIEW: 

Massive Ohio institution.

Born in 1949, Massey's gas-fired, thin-crusted, square-cut cornmeal pizzas have been winning awards and stealing the hearts of Ohioans ever since. The chain has spread across the state, helping to define the classic Midwest style. Nestled inside a bustling commercial center packed with every sort of shop imaginable, Massey's Pizza Sports Bar & Wings beckons patrons with a lineup of all that is good in the world: pizza, beer, televisions, video games, patio seating, and wings!

Step inside, and the cavernously high ceilings almost make you feel like you’ve entered a cathedral of pizza. When it comes to ordering, their signature Pepperoni pie is an absolute must—loaded with so many overlapping pieces of pepperoni that it looks like a gorgeous rose of meat. I recommend starting with at least one of those before branching out into their specialty pies. If you can't decide between the spicy Buffalo chicken, the carnivorous Meat Feast, or the almost-healthy Veggie pie, do yourself a favor and order small 8-inch versions of all three! Just don’t be shy about asking for a dipping sauce to give any leftover crusts an extra kick. Massey's Pizza has been rolling strong for over 75 years, and hopefully, they'll be keeping the ovens hot for at least 75 more!

 


PHOTOS:

Rotating gas powered oven that is over 70 years old

Another view of another rotating surface of oven

slice of 8" Buffalo Chicken

underside

Day 10

Perhaps the smallets slice of pizza ever?

8" Veggie pie

8" Buffalo Chicken pie

14" Pepperoni pie

8".Meat Feast pie

pizza mneu

Front of the Massey's menu

outdoor dining area

interior view #1

interior view #2

VIDEO:

click to view

MISCELLANEOUS: 

Lori Taylor, Sean Taylor, Kitzi Taylor, Jay Taylor

1. Jay Taylor has more protein shakes at his house than most Nutrition stores.

Sean, Lori, Jay at a loading dock in the bowels of Columbus around midnight

2. Lori Taylor has an amazing sense of direction and intuition - trust her when navigating streets late at night, even when she has never been to the city before. 

Kitzi's moral compass

3. Kitzi Taylor has a moral compass, literally.

RATING:

 4.29/5

• VALUE:
   4/5


• AMBIENCE:
   3/3


• TASTE:
   8/10


• SERVICE: 
   3/3

18/21 = .857 x 5 = 4.29